A CNN headline recently read: Former head of CDC believes that the Coronavirus came from a lab in Wuhan. Below the headline it said that he gave no clear evidence. But the disclaimer will not be important to most people who read the headline. Many will believe that the virus came from a Chinese lab, so more reason to hate China. They think that the head of the CDC must be telling the truth. But lets look at the facts here.
Robert Redfield was the CDC director under Trump. He is supposedly a very smart virologist. But it is also crystal clear what he said is just his opinion and not something most scientists who looked into this agree with. Redfield has a history of giving wrong opinions and facts. He has been known to give fake graphs in scientific presentations and as a researcher of AIDS had touted a potential vaccine as effective. This was not opinion shared by other scientists and it turns out we have no effective vaccine for HIV even today.
I think as the case of many people in the U.S. government, Redfield is attacking China to deflect blame for his own incompetence. This is not as bad as calling the China virus or kung flu to deflect blame. But this is not something he would have said if he had done is job well at the CDC. Regardless of whether you believe China was transparent in the beginning, the truth is that the U.S. got its first case at the same date as South Korea. Yet there is no pandemic in South Korea. Or for that matter most places in Asia. While South Korea went into action, our CDC under Redfield came up with inaccurate test kits. When Germany offered to sell us test kits, our CDC refused the offer. So that delay caused many lives.
As head of CDC, Redfield should have given accurate, consistent messages and directions to the public. Yet in the beginning the CDC said wearing masks only prevent those with the virus from spreading to others, not preventing uninfected people from catching the virus. There were also many times last year where Trump was giving false statements and Redfield did not fire back. So Redfield has been incompetent and is not someone we should be listening to.
One thing that strike me the most was when Redfield talked about speaking to his Chinese counterpart early during the pandemic. He said the Chinese scientist was crying because the death rate at that time in China was 5% of those infected, a very high death percentage. I don't remember Redfield mention that he or any American official cried when over 500,000 Americans died from the virus. If there is no empathy for the death of so many, why would there be concern for rhetoric that would open up more hate for Asian Americans?