I was watching a Youtube video by a France television station on forced labor in Xinjiang, China. I wanted to see what new evidence they came up with. The presentation was so bad that I wondered if this is a parody on Western media. But I don't think it is and I think that most people in France who watched this will think that forced labor is real.
During the entire presentation from this "journalist" based in Beijing had a video in the background showing cotton being picked in Xinjiang with large machines. The only humans were the drivers of these machines. So are the drivers forced to drive? Are the machines being forced to work? There was not one single person bending over to pick cotton. If they don't have videos of forced labor, then don't run anything in the background. This just boost China's claim that they bought lots of machines from Deere and this was much more efficient than forcing people to pick cotton by hand.
The "journalist" also said he had no first hand information about forced labor but that from "reliable, independent sources" he said that more people than in the past working in the fields are Uyghurs from Xinjiang as opposed to people from other provinces. Well, if there are people in California who needs jobs, would you bring in people from New York to pick strawberries?
By the way, there was only one "reliable and independent source" he quoted. That was the Global Center for Cooperative Security. It is easy to look up this organization and see how "independent" it is. According its own site, 95% of funding are from governments. The dozen or so governments listed are all Western countries except for Japan. Ironically, France is not one of the nations mentioned although the European Union is. If an organization is 95% funded by China and Russia, would you believe it is independent in reporting forced labor in the U.S.?
Despite these shortcomings, I think most people in France and elsewhere in the Western world will believe that this video is strong evidence of force labor in Xinjiang. I would not be surprised that like articles in other Western media on this subject, it will be quoted elsewhere in the future as evidence. It is like Trump retweet something absurd and next thing you know, millions believe it is true. That is how propaganda works.