Dr. Ming Lin, an emergency physician was fired by his hospital because he was speaking out in social media about the lack of safety measures for patients and staff during this pandemic. He had gone to executives of the hospital first and only went public when he saw the response was inadequate. He is not an isolated case, according to the American College of Emergency Physicians. It is incredible to me that in this time of crisis, that physicians on the front line, are being dismissed for speaking up. Isn't it similar to the reprimand the government in Wuhan gave to Dr. Li when he spoke up?
I don't think that Dr. Lin's firing is race related. But there are news of more Asian Americans being attacked as the casualties of the COVID-19 increase. As the number of deaths increases here in the U.S. and the conditions in China return to normal, you can bet that attacks on Asian American will increase even more. Right now, I am sure the attacks are perpetuated by racists or people who have little knowledge of the world. But that is changing.
Tim Pool, who has a big following on Youtube, ranted about this whole thing was China trying to kill Americans and become number one in the world. You would not label him as a racist or some babbling idiot. He came to fame when he covered Occupying Wall Street and used a drone which produced a video showing a cop attacking a protester. The video contradicted what the cop reported afterward. Pool became a darling of the left and was a Sanders supporter in 2016. He has sided with refugees in Europe in the past. He also has fans on the right since recently he claims that the mainstream media is biased against conservative.
So agree or not agree with him, Pool does not seem to be one who rants without thinking. But his attack on China is backed by no fact or false narratives. The idea that China lied about this whole thing to kill Americans and become dominant is nonsense. As I have pointed out, maybe be the local government in Wuhan made mistakes and delayed things. But even if a medical genius was running this whole thing from day one, it would not have sped up the warning sent out to the world by more than couple of weeks. Pool said that the lies from China were intentional so Trump is not responsible for what happens in the U.S.
So China started this outbreak, killing thousands of its own people, so that the virus will spread to the U.S. and kill many more thousands Americans so China can be dominant? Who in China or anywhere else would think this is great plan? Even if China lied in the beginning, the U.S. and the rest of the world had 2 months head start on China to fight this virus. There are countries whose casualty is minimum compare to the U.S. South Korea, Taiwan and Hong Kong have done well. They were affected way earlier than the U.S. Does Pool think that China believe that the U.S. is less competent than these Asian countries?
I don't know what possesses Pool to rant like this. But as I mentioned in the last blog, the mainstream media is subtly pointing the finger at China. Jake Tapper of CNN said this week that Xi Jinping has blood on his hand for China's slow response. This type of reporting show either a bias agenda or lack of research on how possible infection outbreaks are handled.
Trump has said that Asian Americans should not be targeted because of this pandemic. But he didn't just called this "China virus" at his briefings. He also insisted that the G7 nations use this name instead of COVID-19 in their joint statement after their virtual summit. When the other nations refused, the U.S. didn't sign. Is there any doubt that when things get worse here, Trump will try to shift blame to China? When that happens, Asian Americans will be in even greater danger.
I don't know who this Tim Pool is, so I will have to take your word for what his past videos were about. I have a distrust on some things that governments put out there. I have no idea that the Chinese or American governments are lying about numbers. Is it coincidence that major doctors have been silenced? Are there more people who have been silenced or is this just something that's been reported? I found an interesting article about memos that were sent to the White House early on. My question is, if these were true, did they sit on this information and ignore it? It seems to me that it would have saved a lot of lives if the government acted earlier. There's no doubt about that, correct? Would addressing things earlier caused panic? Here's the article:
ReplyDeletehttps://www.businessinsider.com/trump-was-warned-peter-navarro-millions-could-die-coronavirus-2020-4?fbclid=IwAR24ZXZZvl1fr2huXjMMcry7oCQPonPiSLhGEmRy45N-gdZjN3SPFq0CeH4
If I remember correctly, California was one of the earlier stay at home states. How successful has it been? Has there been a flattening of the curve?
-LBOAYM
There is no question that the numbers from any country are probably low. I don't think it is due to intentional lying. The CDC admitted that early on some pneumonia deaths were due to COVID-19 but they didn't know what they were dealing with. Same with China. In the beginning China only reported cases that had definite positive tests from the lab. Later on they counted them when they had chest x-ray or CT scan positive so they had a large number increase for a few days. Here, we have not tested enough so obviously we have under counted. So when Tim Pool said that if India was where this started, we would have gotten a better picture, that is laughably dumb. Is there anyone in the world who believes that India only has about 5,000 cases now? Go back and see how many cases of the Swine flu was reported in the beginning and see the count the CDC gave years later.
ReplyDeletePeter Navarro is a trade hawk and one of Trump's favorite. He is touting the effectiveness of chloroquine as a treatment for this pandemic. He even argued with Tony Fauci over this even though he is not a medical doctor. He claims that as a social scientist (PhD in economics), he can read data. Laughable! But he did give warnings to Trump. But I guess Trump worried that if words leaked out, then the market will fall and thus hurting his reelection. Well, the market plummeted anyway and panic did set in, especially in grocery stores. Just as the Wuhan government did not want bad news and tried to shut down a doctor, I am sure Trump tried to shut down the CDC. As I said before, the CDC had presence in China. But there was little or no warning about the possibility of the U.S. being hit hard early on from the CDC.
California has done well compare to some other states, given that a lot of people come into the country by way of SF or LA. California has less cases and deaths than Michigan and Louisiana despite much bigger population. SF had instituted restrictions before it had any confirmed cases. But will have to see the next couple of weeks when the peak should hit and see if California is a great success or not.
Racism is present in all groups. Since China started to get back to normalcy, people are coming back to China. Even though most of the people coming back are Chinese, some foreigners also are coming back in. Since most of the new cases in China are from people coming into the country, there is now discrimination against foreigners. There has been report that foreigners are looked upon with suspicion and sometimes are refused service in restaurants and hotels.
ReplyDeleteThere is rumors going around that some Nigerians had come into the country and refusing to be quarantined and has been infecting people. So now some black people, regardless where they came from and most had been in the country all along, are being discriminated against. Some are even kicked out of where they have been living!
The government has put out public service announcements that racial profiling is wrong. But the police has been slow in protecting the rights of foreigners in some place. I was dismayed to find that this has been going on in Guangzhou. Consider that Guangzhou is where most overseas Chinese came from, surely people there know the discrimination Cantonese people face abroad. I would think that there will be outrage that some people in Guangzhou would discriminate against foreigners.