Sunday, June 14, 2020

The killing of black men and women by police in the U.S. has been making news all over the world.  Racism is obviously a big concern.  But I read that U.S. cops kill citizens of all colors at a higher rate than the cops in other countries.  So yes, we need to figure out a way that blacks and other minorities are treated the same as whites by the police.  But if we don't decrease the overall killings by the police, then an equal death by cop rate among all citizens still mean a lot of people who should not have been killed.

One reason I think that cops in this country kill more is the gun culture.  In the UK, Germany, Japan etc., the police are less likely to be confronting someone with a gun and so they are less likely to get into a shootout.  Not only that, the thought that the person you are confronting is more likely to have a gun will make you more likely to pull the trigger yourself.  A Japanese cop facing a drunk guy reaching for his pocket is not likely to believe the guy is reaching for a gun.  So less likely the cop himself will pull his gun and shoot.  Cops shot a kid in Ohio who was holding a toy gun.  I am not excusing this carelessness but in what country would a cop think that a 10 year old is holding a real gun?

The so called Blue Line of Silence and the powerful police unions contribute to the problem by protecting rogue cops.  I am not sure if these two problems exist in other countries but I suspect that it is more so in this country.  It seems a lot of people in this country consider snitching on someone is worse than the crime that the person committed in the first place.  The guy who killed Floyd had many complaints against him by the public.  If that is the case, shouldn't his partners also have complained about him?  There are many people who are hired into police departments who should not be cops.  But the screening process is far from perfect.  Without on the job evaluations by fellow cops, the dangerous cops will stay on the force and commit crimes.

So I believe that we have to change the culture about snitching.  We should applaud those who come forward with legitimate concerns in all walks of life.  Cops are not the only ones protected by the culture on silence.  Priests and doctors are other examples of powerful people who in the past have not been reported for doing something wrong.  The player who squealed on the Astros for their cheating in the world series have been shunned by some players.  That is not right.  We should be more concern about calling out wrongs and not more concern about supporting those who did wrong.

Back to the problem of racism in police forces.  While it is important that we have better training to combat racism, I think there are people in the forces who are racists to begin with and no matter the training, they are not going to change.  These are probably a small minority.  But to get rid of them, other officers have to speak out.  We need to change the culture.  I saw on tv last night that a cop actually went against another cop's testimony regarding a shooting.  The cop was shunned and had to retire from the force.  This needs to change.

2 comments:

  1. Anonymous7:29 PM

    Interesting take. I can't disagree with you, but I just don't think we will ever be able to change the gun culture in the U.S. So, for me, we need to find a more practical answer to this. What that is, I'm not sure.

    My thought is that we need better training of police. Maybe do it like other countries where they go a couple years of learning and training and testing. I think a psychological test needs to be done in order for someone to be an officer. There needs to be more people of color and various backgrounds to be recruited as well.

    They also need to do away with these traffic stops where the cop sees a black person and they decide to pull them over. There was a great column by former Detroit Chief of Police Ike MacKinnon this past weekend talking about how he was pulled over while he was chief. The officer who pulled him over ended up being fired. But we hear about this type of abuse all the time. We hear about black people getting hassled by cops while they are just standing around or jay walking.

    For me, it's not too late to send all cops to more training and to get them evaluated psychologically. Weed out the bad ones. My only concern is that these bad apples will be out in the street without jobs and they might have an axe to grind.

    -LBOAYM

    ReplyDelete
  2. One time I heard on the radio where a former cop said that in a force, one third of the cops are good, one third is mediocre, and the last third are terrible, either bullies or victims of bullies when they were young and now uses force on others to compensate for the past. That is a scary thought and if true then no amount of training will change those last third. They have no business being cops. And you can't weed them out because the union will say that the psychological tests are not accurate and discriminatory. So only being caught in the act can these cops be fired. So if not caught on camera, you need the good ones to speak out on what they witnessed.

    Surprising good news from the Supreme Court which affirmed that LGBTQ people cannot be discriminated against in the work place. Roberts, who voted against same sex marriage in the past, voted the other way this time. And Trump's appointee Gorusch actually wrote the decision for the majority. Wow, there is hope in this conservative Court for civil rights yet!

    ReplyDelete

Use the following html code to make a clickable link in your comment (instructions in the sidebar). You can test the link by previewing your comment.

<a href="http://angryyellowman.blogspot.com">Angry Yellow Man</a>

The above example will display as Angry Yellow Man